have stooped to planting a VAR to catch her,
Catch her doing what?
Our collective experience on this site has taught us a lot about infidelity. Now – your instance might be the one that breaks the rules or proves the exception but here are some trends and behaviors that we recognize that are predictable.
The first thing that comes to mind is your reaction. A reluctance to reach the logical assumptions based on what you know. We see a lot of that. The initial reaction is to hope this is less than it is. I remember one guy whose wife admitted to spending a night in a hotel room with her boss and having bought lingerie and sex-toys along, but denied sex. This guy couldn’t decide if she had cheated or not, because he didn’t have "proof" of sex...
Assumptions are never great, but often they beat not having direct proof. Like if you smell smoke in a hotel room and when you touch the door and it’s hot, you ASSUME there is a fire. You don’t have to open the door to see the flames. I think you might be trying to "catch her" to see the flames, when you already have the smoke, the hot door and the ringing of fire-alarms...
This was/is a sexual affair. If there was sexual content shared with the intent of causing arousal... it’s sex.
It’s also highly likely that two adults that are sexting or doing online sex for FIVE years and that have an environment where they can relatively easily meet in person don’t do "real" sex. Imagine all the opportunities: a closed office, that "meeting" he took her along with, that conference/car show she attended, that hookup in a vehicle during lunch, the office-supply room that nobody uses, that time she went to work early, that time she had to work Saturday...
He hired her to have her near him. Why would he do that if it’s "only" cyber? You don’t get aroused any more if your favorite porn-site is housed a block away rather than cross-country. It’s online – distance is irrelevant.
You say yourself that this was a career change and that she has DEVELOPED into a great car salesperson. So, she wasn’t head-hunted or anything like that. He didn’t pick her out for her proven sales abilities. He hired her to have her near. Why? If this was cyber-sex, then why?
The logic simply does not add up to this being more emotional and less physical.
Now – I could be wrong. Like I said early on we build on shared experience and I’m basing my analysis on shared experience and logic. MAYBE your wife is the unicorn. But frankly – YOU DON’T KNOW.
THAT is a key issue. You don’t have the truth.
Frankly – I have yet to see a successful reconciliation where the betrayed spouse isn’t clear on what went on.
I have seen couples reconcile from really dire situations – multiple affairs, abuse, separation... – but if they reconcile then they both know the basis they are reconciling from. Seen plenty "reconcile" where they rug-sweep the issues, but that doesn’t really last.
Then you have the situation where she blames you for what she did/is doing.
If something YOU did "forced" her into having an affair... how can you prevent a repeat? After all – say you forget to pick up milk on the way home; would that justify her giving the neighbor oral sex?
A KEY-FACTOR in recovery is the admittance that no matter how the relationship was, the decision to have an affair is a) totally the decision of the wayward spouse and b) has nothing to do with what the betrayed spouse said or did.
One thing we have seen repeated about a gazillion times here on this site: A promise that what wasn’t an affair is "over" and that nothing is going on. Also – like in your instance – where the partner of the OP has been informed.
Your WW and her AP work together... Do you really think a 5 year "addiction" can be quit cold-turkey if you have your drug-of-choice right in front of you? IMHO the odds are something like 19/20 that they have taken this underground. Like... "your husband found the sexting, so let’s not do that anymore", or "my wife questions why I work Saturdays so maybe I don’t do that anymore" – followed by "but we can hook up during lunch" or "we can sext while commuting" or whatever.
With 19/20 odds... your best option is to assume it’s ongoing.
Then there is the key-factor our collective experience has learned: There has to be no contact with the affair partner.
With them working together... that’s not happening. We strongly advocate that the WS leaves the job if it’s a workplace affair.
Friend – I’m not painting a pretty picture... But I think I am painting a true picture based on what you share – along with our collective experience. I think your safest and possibly only option is to believe your logical assumptions and then leave it to HER to disprove them OR prove them right.
So back to the first question I asked: What is it you want to catch her doing? Why? Why not just assume it’s ongoing until she can convince you otherwise.
What would I suggest?
Well... Think long and hard about the worst-case scenario. You are thinking that it’s losing your wife... Well... is that the worst? If so – then allow her to have her affair. After all since it’s been going on for five years then OM isn’t going to divorce and then marry her. Give it time, and maybe in 2-3 years he finds a new sputnik-salesWOMAN...
This way you have a happy wife and she is likely to stay.
Does that sound good? If not then really evaluate what is the worst outcome?
I think you will realize that the worst outcome is ongoing infidelity... That not having your wife despite her being there is even worse than not having her. That in reality you don’t have a marriage as long as she is having an affair.
I suggest you give her the following speech:
"Wife – I always envisioned us growing old together as husband and wife. However I have realized that as long as you are having an affair with OM then at best I share you. I don’t share my wife. I have also realized that even worse than not having you is sharing you.
Since you are committed to your affair with OM then all I can do is refuse to share. You are free to be with, date, spend time with and do whatever you want with OM – but not as my wife. I am initiating the steps – both legally and emotionally – in terminating our marriage.
This isn’t what I want, but even less do I want to share you. If you want this marriage you have a short window of opportunity to let me know, as well as to comply to some requirements about accountability and truth, but you need to understand that I am content with my decision and the further I go the better I accept it."
Then go make a sandwich.
If she wants to tell you why you made her have to have an affair...
"I’m sorry you feel that way. If we were working on our marriage, this might be addressed in MC. Since you are committed to your affair there isn’t any need to address this. Want a sandwich?"
No matter what issue she throws at you – the above is the standard answer (sans the sandwich maybe).
If she wants details about the D process:
"I am too emotionally attached to this marriage to make rational decisions on these practical matters. Inevitably we will be living separately and our debts and assets divided, but until then I will leave it to those that have the legal knowledge to deal with this"
Basically – you turn into a gray rock. You don’t feel her any emotional response. You have set your course and are following it. You can change course if she responds, but for now you are working your way OUT of infidelity.
[This message edited by SI Staff at 12:22 PM, Thursday, April 10th]